Flag desecration arrest in North Carolina


The Volokh Conspiracy notes the arrest of an Asheville, North Carolina couple for improper flag display — they flew the U.S. flag upside down (a universal sign of distress), and with protest notes attached to it.

Details from the Asheville Citizen-Times.

The newspaper also notes that the flag desecration statute appears not to have been used since the Vietnam War era (anybody care to guess which political views got cited?) . A local fireworks sales stand in the area displayed U.S. flags in violation of the Flag Code near July 4, but while news abstracts appear to show the stand was cited for a violation of the sign code, there is no indication it was cited for the flag desecration code.

We need to amend the Flag Code, to authorize flag displays that have become popular recently, such as shirts that resemble the flag, flag decals in autos, flag bumper stickers, and other displays that technically violate the Flag Code — unless, of course, we want to try to criminalize innocent attempts to honor the flag. Flag desecration cases almost always have a political component, however, and such prosecutions should generally be suspect under the First Amendment — don’t you agree?

How much of the ire against the Kuhns in Asheville was prompted by their support of Ron Paul for president? (See the photo of their protest signs, and note the lawn sign in the background.) Mark and Deborah Kuhn show their flag protest signs, after arrest incident

If someone has the details of the fireworks stand case near Asheville, please send them along — was the stand in the same county as Mark and Deborah Kuhn?

UpdateThe Mountain Xpress story carries a slightly different tone, identifying the Kuhns as “activists,” and featuring interviews of eyewitnesses to the arrests.

Other improper flag displays, below the fold.

Improper display at an Operation Rescue/Operation Save America rally in Wichita, Kansas, in 2001. The U.S. flag should be to its right, and not lower than other flags (this example does not qualify for the shipboard, religious services exception).

Improper flag display in Wichita, Kansas, 2001

Here’s a display that might be interpreted as flag desecration, though it seems clear that is not the intent of the creator of the item, on sale from Aspencountry.com. Would such a device be contrary to the flag desecration law in North Carolina?
Flag wall plaque

Below is a technically incorrect display of a flag by the U.S. Navy aboard the U.S.S. Intrepid on May 29, 2006. The flag displayed is probably too large to be displayed correctly aboard ship. Would such a display be illegal in Asheville? Should it be contrary to the Flag Code at all?

Giant US flag displayed aboard USS Intrepid, May 29, 2006

Fourth of July exhibit in Boston, July 4, 2001; photo from Habeeb.com. Notice the flag against the wall is backwards.
Confucius and flags, Boston, July 4, 2001

Kids wearing the U.S. flag, contrary to U.S. Flag Code; Wyandotte, Michigan, Fourth of July Parade, 2002. Photo from Habeeb.com.

Kids wearing flags, Wyandotte, Mich, 7-4-2002

Kid Rock performing at the Super Bowl — few protested his desecration of the flag (ripping it, wearing it, disposing of it in an undignified manner) and this performance is best remembered for Janet Jackson’s bared breast (in a world of prudes, so many moral infractions to police — which gets priority?). (The photo is uncredited from my source.)

Kid Rock improperly displaying flag at Super Bowl

President Bush signing a U.S. flag during the 2004 election, which would be a violation of the Asheville ordinance as it was applied to the Kuhns, I believe.

President Bush signing a flag, contrary to U.S. Flag Code.If Bush can put a campaign message on a flag, why can’t the Kuhns do the same?

About these ads

7 Responses to Flag desecration arrest in North Carolina

  1. Ozzlin' Daddy says:

    Giant US flag displayed aboard USS Intrepid, May 29, 2006> Link

    Link has died and gone to the Great Internet Heaven.

    My comment does not bear posting, thanks.

    Like

  2. Eddie says:

    Thanks for the article. It’s good to review the US Flag code American Flag Etiquette http://www.uncleflag.com/American-Flag-Etiquette-s/500.htm

    Like

  3. KRC says:

    I’m looking for James Kennedy. I think I may have a message for him or maybe from him. Box 40. Please reply personally.

    Like

  4. [...] Flag desecration arrest in North Carolina [...]

    Like

  5. Ed Darrell says:

    The rules on flag displays with foreign flags are in USC 4, Ch 1, section 7:

    http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/html/uscode04/usc_sec_04_00000007—-000-.html

    Like

  6. Isn’t it correct to fly foreign flags at the same height as the American flag?

    Like

  7. Ellie says:

    In my city, there are three flags flown at the FBI building: the American flag, the Canadian flag, and the FBI flag. They are all flown at the same height. At the mall where I work, the American flag and the Canadian flag are flown at the same height. This, apparently, is perfectly OK, although certainly contrary to the United States Flag Code. It is obvious that only when dissenting views are offered, is the Flag Code enforced at all.

    Like

Play nice in the Bathtub -- splash no soap in anyone's eyes.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 2,278 other followers

%d bloggers like this: