DDT fanatic a former Monsanto lobbyist?


Sometimes in unexpected places you stumble across a factoid that makes sense out of a lot of other factoids, turning them into enlightening, and perhaps useful, information.

Steven Milloy used to be a Monsanto lobbyist?  Is that accurate?

Among the allegations, that Monsanto aggressively protects its patents on seeds and other products sold to farmers, and that the company may not be above a bit of skullduggery to push farmers and, in this case, milk processors, to use Monsanto products.  Watch for Steven Milloy’s name to pop up in the last paragraph.  The site quotes a Vanity Fair  article on Monsanto from 2008.

Even if Monsanto’s efforts to secure across-the-board labeling changes should fall short, there’s nothing to stop state agriculture departments from restricting labeling on a dairy-by-dairy basis. Beyond that, Monsanto also has allies whose foot soldiers will almost certainly keep up the pressure on dairies that don’t use Monsanto’s artificial hormone. Jeff Kleinpeter knows about them, too.

He got a call one day from the man who prints the labels for his milk cartons, asking if he had seen the attack on Kleinpeter Dairy that had been posted on the Internet. Kleinpeter went online to a site called StopLabelingLies, which claims to “help consumers by publicizing examples of false and misleading food and other product labels.” There, sure enough, Kleinpeter and other dairies that didn’t use Monsanto’s product were being accused of making misleading claims to sell their milk.

There was no address or phone number on the Web site, only a list of groups that apparently contribute to the site and whose issues range from disparaging organic farming to downplaying the impact of global warming. “They were criticizing people like me for doing what we had a right to do, had gone through a government agency to do,” says Kleinpeter. “We never could get to the bottom of that Web site to get that corrected.”

As it turns out, the Web site counts among its contributors Steven Milloy, the “junk science” commentator for FoxNews.com and operator of junkscience.com, which claims to debunk “faulty scientific data and analysis.” It may come as no surprise that earlier in his career, Milloy, who calls himself the “junkman,” was a registered lobbyist for Monsanto.

If accurate, it’s a sort of “origins” story — I don’t think it explains Milloy’s current advocacy of DDT and almost all other things anti-environmentally-wise.  Nor does it explain Milloy’s penchant for making things up whole cloth.  Does Fox News disclose this anywhere?

It does suggest his dirty tricks chops against environmentalists and scientists get exercised more than I had imagined.

The story is an interesting and odd footnote in the debunking of the unholy War on Science that claims Rachel Carson was wrong, and DDT is harmless and right.

More: 

About these ads

4 Responses to DDT fanatic a former Monsanto lobbyist?

  1. Jim says:

    Two words for anyone who would dare defend Monsanto:

    Anniston, Alabama.

    If you’re still defending Monsanto after that, I have two more words for you. But this is a “family” blog…so you’ll just have to use your imagination.

    Like

  2. Ed Darrell says:

    The reputation of the reporters — two Pulitzers, two National Magazine Awards — the otherwise solid reporting from Vanity Fair on a variety of other issues, and the corroboration from five other sites, and other care, all speak to the veracity of this article in that magazine (did you check the stuff at the bottom of the post?).

    FDA is bound by law to make labeling regulations that work, and are accurate. They may not do so on a whim. For milk, I don’t think FDA has much say at all — isn’t that USDA at the federal level?

    One should neither foolishly believe nor disbelieve anything one reads on the internet. Instead, check it out for yourself.

    I had one question that you offer no opinion on: Was Steven Milloy a lobbyist for Monsanto?

    Maybe you could start your search on the internet, and then verify.

    Like

  3. Tony says:

    should read what makes you think…..

    Like

  4. Tony says:

    what makes you think that an article in vanity fair is informed or correct. we can’t have a society that created fictitous health concerns or benefits based on false science or facts. We can’t let endless labeling and false advertising to prevail, Its bad enough that the US spends billions on quack medicine nd food supplements most of which do nothing some of which do real harm and only a few are actually active the way they say they are. Th FDA allows labeling when it is relevant. If food is changed from the norm in content it can and should be labeled BGH treated cows don’t produce milk that is harmful to people – thus a fact. If you are stupid and ignorant you will believe anything on the internet

    Like

Play nice in the Bathtub -- splash no soap in anyone's eyes.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 2,223 other followers

%d bloggers like this: