December 19, 2012
It was a class project, a class project in CGI.
The baby-stealing eagle in Montreal? Computer generated. No real eagles were harmed in the process (no word about osprey or falcons, though . . .)
Luisa posted this in comments to the previous post:
Je suis désolée:
The blog at CentreNAD said:
19 December 2012
The “Golden Eagle Snatches Kid” video, uploaded to YouTube on the evening of December 18, was made by Normand Archambault, Loïc Mireault and Félix Marquis-Poulin, students at Centre NAD, in the production simulation workshop class of the Bachelors degree in 3D Animation and Digital Design.
The video shows a royal eagle snatching a young kid while he plays under the watch of his dad. The eagle then drops the kid a few feet away. Both the eagle and the kid were created in 3D animation and integrated in to the film afterwards.
The video has already received more than 1,200,000 views on YouTube and has been mentioned by dozens of media in Canada and abroad.
The production simulation workshop class, offered in fifth semester, aims to produce creative projects according to industry production and quality standards while developing team work skills. Hoaxes produced in this class have already garnered attention, amongst others a video of a penguin having escaped the Montreal Biodôme.
Was that enough YouTube views to guarantee an A in the course?
I’ll wager the students who made the film are not “désolée” at all.
Grateful tip of the old scrub brush to Luisa, at Crows and Ravens.
.Gif showing shadow inconsistencies used to debunk video: Caption at Poynter.org: “Earlier, social media verification experts at Storyful point to evidence of fakery, including Twitter user @thornae’s animated GIF showing inconsistencies with the eagle’s shadow.”
December 19, 2012
East Coast son Kenny sent this video, noting his reaction was the same as the guy in the film; an encounter with a golden eagle in a Montreal park:
You can take the eagle out of the wild, but you can’t take the wild out of the eagle.
Looks mostly like a golden eagle to me — anyone want to make the case it’s a different bird?
What’s going on in Montreal, I wonder, that would make a golden eagle think a human baby might make a good meal? (No, I don’t think the bird was trying to give the kid a thrill.)
Other reports of similar incidents around Montreal?
Update: WHAT? IT’S FAKED? Thoughtful reader Luisa in comments refers us to Chris Clarke’s Original Blog™ Coyote Crossing, which updates from expert birder Kenn Kauffman who says, as I wondered, it’s not a golden eagle, and other things look hoaxed. (While you’re looking around, check out Luisa’s Crow and Raven; bird photos that will make you jealous.) You’d think an incident like that would have made it to the newspapers and television stations in Montreal, but I’ve found nothing — have you?)
Update, December 19, 2012: Now the CBC covers the tale, noting that it is most likely a hoax. The film’s maker or YouTube poster has not defended it that I can find. Watch carefully — the “baby” doesn’t move during the time it’s on the ground, through the bird’s plucking it up and dropping it. There’s plenty of time to swap a dummy out with a real kid in the stroller while the camera is pointed away. CBC found a Montreal ornithologist who claims it looks more like an osprey than an eagle. I’ll buy that.