Millard Fillmore, statesman. What?


Elektratig relates views in a new book that makes a case that Millard Fillmore acted decisively and powerfully to prevent a war between the states in 1850, and thereby force the Compromise of 1850.

Among its many other virtues, Mark J. Stegmaier’s Texas, New Mexico, & The Compromise of 1850: Boundary Dispute & Sectional Crisis contains a detailed and balanced discussion of Millard Fillmore’s contributions toward the resolution of the Crisis of 1850.

A cartoon from April 1850 shows how raw were some of the emotions among national leaders, especiallyi n the Senate.  It illustrates an incident that occurred April 17, 1850, when Sen. Henry S. Foote of Mississippi drew a pistol on Missouri’s Sen. Thomas Hart Benton.  Elektratig used the cartoon to illustrate his post; it’s good enough to repeat here.

A somewhat tongue-in-cheek dramatization of the moment during the heated debate in the Senate over the admission of California as a free state when Mississippi senator Henry S. Foote drew a pistol on Thomas Hart Benton of Missouri. In the cartoon Benton (center) throws open his coat and defiantly states, Get out of the way, and let the assassin fire! let the scoundrel use his weapon! I have no arms! I did not come here to assassinate! He is attended by two men, one of them North Carolina senator Willie P. Mangum (on the left). Foote, restrained from behind by South Carolinas Andrew Pickens Butler and calmed by Daniel Stevens Dickinson of New York (to whom he later handed over the pistol), still aims his weapon at Benton saying, I only meant to defend myself! In the background Vice President Fillmore, presiding, wields his gavel and calls for order. Behind Foote another senator cries, For Gods sake Gentlemen Order! To the right of Benton stand Henry Clay and (far right) Daniel Webster. Clay puns, Its a ridiculous matter, I apprehend there is no danger on foot! Visitors in the galleries flee in panic.

Cartoon by Edward Williams Clay, from the Library of Congress Collection. LOC Summary: A somewhat tongue-in-cheek dramatization of the moment during the heated debate in the Senate over the admission of California as a free state when Mississippi senator Henry S. Foote drew a pistol on Thomas Hart Benton of Missouri. In the cartoon Benton (center) throws open his coat and defiantly states, "Get out of the way, and let the assassin fire! let the scoundrel use his weapon! I have no arm's! I did not come here to assassinate!" He is attended by two men, one of them North Carolina senator Willie P. Mangum (on the left). Foote, restrained from behind by South Carolina's Andrew Pickens Butler and calmed by Daniel Stevens Dickinson of New York (to whom he later handed over the pistol), still aims his weapon at Benton saying, "I only meant to defend myself!" In the background Vice President Fillmore, presiding, wields his gavel and calls for order. Behind Foote another senator cries, "For God's sake Gentlemen Order!" To the right of Benton stand Henry Clay and (far right) Daniel Webster. Clay puns, "It's a ridiculous matter, I apprehend there is no danger on foot!" Visitors in the galleries flee in panic.

Real history:  Stranger than you can imagine.

2 Responses to Millard Fillmore, statesman. What?

  1. Ed Darrell says:

    VP presides over the Senate. She said the VP runs the Senate. Not the same thing. Notice that while Fillmore bangs the gavel and calls for order, the senators ignore him.

    For example, the majority party’s Policy Committee determines the schedules of bills coming to the floor, and under what rules if different from normal. The majority leader is the person who “runs” the Senate, regardless of who sits in the chair presiding.

    Since Spiro Agnew — the last governor surprise who held the position (inauspicious thought, that) — the VP’s role has been reduced even farther. Agnew wasn’t trusted by the Republicans to spend much time in the Senate, nor to learn the Senate rules, so they urged him to stay away. He did.

    Hubert Humphrey had been a great activist, shuttling from cabinet meetings to the Democratic Policy Committee, making peace and promoting communication between the White House and the Senate. It would be nice to have someone else with his flair for making things go.

    Like

  2. mpb says:

    In the background Vice President Fillmore, presiding, wields his gavel and calls for order.

    So, Palin is right about what the VP does (influences the Senate and policy)?

    Like

Please play nice in the Bathtub -- splash no soap in anyone's eyes. While your e-mail will not show with comments, note that it is our policy not to allow false e-mail addresses. Comments with non-working e-mail addresses may be deleted.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: