One of the most frequent hoax charges against Rachel Carson claims that she didn’t base Silent Spring on research. Greater hoaxers claim that there is little or no evidence of harm to birds from DDT.
These critics forget history, or they try to cover it up so you won’t know any better. Carson provided more than 50 pages of citations to peer-reviewed research and communications with leading scientists in ornithology and chemistry about DDT and the damage it does.
Carson’s deep research won acknowledgment from the U.S. Department of the Interior, in this 1962 speech before the Audubon Society meeting in Corpus Christi, Texas, by the Special Assistant Assistant Secretary for Fish and Wildlife Robert M. Paul.
Paul told the birders that Interior was proud of the fact that so much of the research in the book relied on Interior’s research, from the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service:
In addition, we are proud that so much of ‘Silent Spring“ is based on Fish and Wildlife Service research. And, with no modesty at all, we like to point out that Miss Carson is nobly carrying on a tradition that employees of the Department of the Interior, beginning with Walt Whitman nearly a century ago, have written some of the Nation’s most important books.
That’s quite the compliment to Carson, being compared even distantly to Walt Whitman. It’s also a helluva brag for USFWS.
It’s also a 30-second response to the false charge that Carson’s work was not research based, or that research did not show DDT damage to wildlife.
Paul spoke to the Audubon Society about work to set up and operate the Federal Pest Control Board.
A .pdf of the speech can be found at the website for Interior, in a compilation of information from Interior about DDT between 1945 and 1998. Full text below the fold.